THE GROUP OF ELDERS MINISTRY MODEL VS. THE RELIGIOUS AUTHORITARIAN MODEL [Part 2]

The Lord Jesus is a God of order. However, religious authoritarians are often people of ultra-order in which they and their religion take prominence over people.

.

And there arose also a dispute among them as to which one of them was regarded to be greatest. And He said to them, “The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them; and those who have authority over them are called ‘Benefactors.’ But it is not this way with you, but the one who is the greatest among you must become like the youngest, and the leader like the servant. For who is greater, the one who reclines at the table or the one who serves? Is it not the one who reclines at the table? But I am among you as the one who serves.” [Luke 22:24-27]

SCHOOL DAZE

I remember my initial experience as a kid in first grade. We had relatively large classes back then usually in the 35-40 pupil range. We had the old-fashioned desks in which each unit had the requisite desktop, a curved wooden chair seat, and a metal mini locker under the seat open at both ends to put your books and stuff in. They were constructed very well, made of lacquered wood and painted metal. There was even a little elongated depression rounded out of the wood at the top of the desktop to put your pencil. The desks were arranged in perfectly straight rows about six or seven across and six or seven deep. Everything in the classroom was orderly and clean.

Of course, every desk faced the front. At the front center was the big wooden desk of the teacher and behind the teacher was an entire wall of blackboards. When one first walked into such an arrangement one deciphered pretty quickly that the classroom was a place of ultra-order and decorum. This would not be a place where kids can be kids but one in which kids would be just the opposite in that only prescribed movements would be allowed and no one would ever be allowed to talk unless called upon. A kid would walk in silently, go to his or her desk silently, place their books and stuff in that place under the seat quietly and then sit down. One was usually only allowed to look toward the front. When the teacher was there and class was in session everybody looked only to the front and focused squarely on the teacher. The teacher would thus hold court.

For little kids just getting used to this process and trying to adapt, there was a high level of intimidation. One wanted to make sure he or she was doing everything right and fulfilling the requirements. There was a quickly constructed built-in attitude one was forced to adhere to which stated that the teacher was absolutely totally in charge. We knew this by her stern, no nonsense authoritarian demeanor. I say her because most of my teachers from first through eighth grades were of the female variety but policy dictated that such gender identity was played down in order to enforce rule, which meant the normal caring attitude of the female person was transformed into more of a dictator in chief in that every child must know that respect for authority was paramount.

Maybe you had a different experience, but I was one of millions of children across America that experienced school in this way. It was obviously not a public school. It was one of those denominational schools that wholly rejected such a label since it was the predominant universal “church” on the planet that looked down upon such inferior Christian bodies (actual denominations) of “departed brethren.” And this universal church did not arrive at their level of success across the world without a powerful authoritarian nature that demanded absolute control which bordered on a militaristic ethos.

Regarding personal decorum, the majority of the teachers belonged to a strict religious order and were attired in black from head to toe with only the face showing. Even their entire forehead had a wide white cardboard band across it to the eyebrows. Therefore, it seemed as though not only feminine nature and appearance must be greatly reduced but human nature as well. Also, to add to the militaristic control-oriented authoritarian you-are-a-nobody-only-a-part-of-the-dominant-religious-culture theme, all the boys wore the exact same khaki uniform and the girls wore identical white blouses and dark green skirts.

The overall effect of all this over-the-top religious propriety and order can be, as I’ve stated, quite intimidating for a little kid and such intimidation often gave way to outright fear if one mistakenly broke the rules or failed to show the proper respect for authority and the all-encompassing correctness. There were thus punishments put forth (and sometimes inflicted) which went anywhere from writing lines to that of the actual corporal variety. But the greatest tool in the punishment toolbox used expertly by all the teachers was shaming.

Shame was a powerfully effective weapon. It singled out the individual while everybody else gave silent assent since no one dared to question the process. The powers that be in this organization had learned centuries ago that they must gain control of people when they were very young impressionable children in order to brand upon their young minds respect and obedience to the order. In this process no one was allowed any form of dissent or resistance. One will note it is this same process used on young raw military recruits by hard core in-you-face screaming drill sergeants. The recruits must lose all sense of their prior selves and individual identities in order to be transformed into the necessary group dynamic killing machines they must become if war would have a good chance of victory.

Yet such discipline used on small defenseless children in which their minds are melded into an indoctrinated religious mass grouping before they ever have the chance to think for themselves is not good, especially since such is for the sake of an institution and the power and wealth of those who run it. Such a process not only constitutes a loss of the innocence of childhood but could very well also keep one from an actual relationship with the Lord Jesus.

It is also in direct opposition to His pure teachings:

Then some children were brought to Him so that He might lay His hands on them and pray; and the disciples rebuked them. But Jesus said, “Let the children alone, and do not hinder them from coming to Me; for the kingdom of heaven belongs to such as these.” [Matthew 19:13-14]

Truly I say to you, whoever does not receive the kingdom of God like a child will not enter it at all.” [Luke 18:17] [1] 

 © 2025 by RJ Dawson. All Rights Reserved. [To Be Continued…]


[1] Unless otherwise noted all Scriptures are taken from the New American Standard Bible, © 1960, 1963, 1968, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1975, 1977, 1995 by The Lockman Foundation. Used by permission.

Posted on March 5, 2025, in Teaching and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 6 Comments.

  1. Excellent teaching, RJ. We had authoritarian teachers when I was a kid in secular school, and sadly, Sunday school wasn’t much better at times. Fear and religious indoctrination instead of love can totally skew a child’s perspective of life and God. Lord, protect our children today and always. 🙏💖🙏

    Like

    • Thank you Susan. Many similarities between these two, as well as big church. In my next post I hope to show how the real Church under the Lord’s control and authority looks like something uncontrolled with no proper authority or order to the religious authoritarians. It is in large part why such people refuse the Book of Acts/New Covenant model. Blessings

      At that time the disciples came to Jesus and said, “Who then is greatest in the kingdom of heaven?” And He called a child to Himself and set him before them, and said, “Truly I say to you, unless you are converted and become like children, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven. Whoever then humbles himself as this child, he is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven. And whoever receives one such child in My name receives Me; but whoever causes one of these little ones who believe in Me to stumble, it would be better for him to have a heavy millstone hung around his neck, and to be drowned in the depth of the sea.” [Matthew 18:1-6]

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Thank you for sharing your experience, RJ, which I can truly relate. I had exactly the same training from Kindergarten through High School, based on fear and intimidation, autocratic, disciplinarian to the utmost. I am re-living the words on your post — “the majority of the teachers belonged to a strict religious order and were attired in black from head to toe with only the face showing. Even their entire forehead had a wide white cardboard band across it to the eyebrows.” Regarding my experience, these teachers flew all the way from Belgium to Asia. The punishments to those who just minutely “diverted” from their rules were severe – like going to the back of the classroom with arms overstretched throughout the whole class period, to having our palms slapped by a wooden ruler by the teachers, etc. etc. Keep our mouths closed, no chatting, be silent at all times. This will be reflected in our “Conduct” grade every grading period.

    Needless to say, I figured there must be a better way. And I found the Lord’s love and His way – the way of liberty wherewith Christ has set us free, and not entangled again with the yoke of bondage.

    I must say though, this must be the reason for your excellent grammar! I still find myself trying to correct the spelling and grammar of some random articles I read along the way, inherently acquired from all the perfectionist standards taught by those teachers in grade/high school! Anyway, thank you for this post, RJ. This brought me back to my nostalgic childhood years.

    Like

    • What a great blessing it is to me that you enjoyed this post and we have much the same childhood experience. It sounds like you might have had it tougher than me, but maybe not. I think you have let me know through your really good comment here, Dee, that I might need to share more life experiences in my posts. You wrote:

      “Thank you for sharing your experience, RJ, which I can truly relate. I had exactly the same training from Kindergarten through High School, based on fear and intimidation, autocratic, disciplinarian to the utmost. I am re-living the words on your post — ”

      This is high praise. Thank you. I have a decided tendency to often keep things academic in my posts because I want to teach (my spiritual gifting) but we can also bless each other by relaying experiences, of course. I may need to find a better balance. I say this because you were really affected by what I wrote. I know we all probably have maybe at least the vestiges of unresolved issues although mature Christians get such things taken care of over time through the Lord’s ways. Maybe it is not so much unsolved stuff but just being blessed to share some things we usually don’t with someone who can relate.

      The Good News, of course, is that we later met the Lord Jesus! This has made all the difference. You wrote:

      “Needless to say, I figured there must be a better way. And I found the Lord’s love and His way – the way of liberty wherewith Christ has set us free, and not entangled again with the yoke of bondage.”

      Amen to that. Regarding my schooling, I must admit that I got a fairly good education but the bigger application regarding school was just getting through it and looking forward to completing it and getting it over with. I left that denomination as a senior in High School.

      The Lord’s teaching method is so much better. The entire school structure in general is really lousy and the only reason it can work is through a lot of force and, you guessed it, authoritarianism and strict discipline. It is probably why education in America is at such a low ebb at present and why so many are so clueless and not knowledgeable of even the basics. It is because the discipline of the past is no longer being applied. Students are being coddled. Not only does this result in ignorance but also laziness. This is in general, of course, since there are still a great many hard working bright kids getting it done.

      Regarding my grammar, thank you! I don’t think I’m much of a grammatician but maybe my grammar has somehow gotten better. I have worked very hard over many years honing my craft and regardless of where my writing is now it is better than what it was as a young man. Such development usually only comes through use and it often takes a lot of work over many years.

      This is why so many Christians are not spiritually developed as they should be. The only way to do it since church time is so brief is to work 95% of the time on your own. It is why the Lord’s disciples were full time students, 24 hours a day. This is why they developed so fast, relatively speaking, after being so clueless in the beginning. The Lord Jesus is the BEST Teacher. And because He is not restricted by time and space, he can devote Himself 24 hours a day to each of His children.

      Thanks again, Dee. Always great to hear from you. Keep up the very good work you do and keep shining your light. People need you. Later

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Wow. That’s quite a description. I’m thankful to say I did NOT have such a militaristic experience when I was so young. Our teacher was young, very pretty, and engaged to be married. We had fun in the classroom, and I was so excited to be able to READ! Still, that was back in the time when we were taught at home to respect authority, and to obey the rules. I was only six; it was 1952, and “I Like Ike” was the popular slogan of the day. It was also the year of the first Salk vaccine for polio. It was the year that the words “Under God” were added to the Pledge of Allegiance. And there were still air raid shelters in the building, with barrels of water and other supplies. A different age, for sure.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks my friend. I appreciate the comparative. Sounds like a great experience and much more in keeping with Christian values and true New Covenant principles. The country was much smaller then, the population being less than half of what it is now. It was still largely rural or at least had rural values. The religious order which staffed my school had to be imported which explains its lack of American values and understanding. It is sad to see what has happened to the country since those days but it has all been by design with a set agenda for evil purposes. The kids have been the greater victim.

      I also appreciate your continued support. Blessings

      Like

Leave a reply to RJ Dawson Cancel reply