HARD HEART VS. TENDER HEART: TWO MODELS FOR LIVING
One model is as the socially popular Broad Way though it leads to eventual ruin. The other appears counterintuitive yet is the bountiful Way of Life.
.
A REJECTION OF THE REAL
There are many things about our world that are very difficult to deal with. There are a great many realities that force us to face such facts though we would usually rather not and may even wish such facts did not exist. As we grow out of childhood some begin to become aware of the existence of an upcoming forced change of course and one’s eventual coerced embrace of hard truths. While other young ones or maybe most do not perceive this early on it eventually becomes quite evident. Many children do not want to leave their innocent carefree childhood life behind and embrace such difficult truths and would greatly prefer to maintain their status quo as children.
But future adulthood beckons. Young children may never wonder so much about the great mystery of adults, how they came to be, and the far-out idea that they were once children also. It is simply too much to fathom and for the most part does not compute. Their reality is such that they must be protected from life early on yet also must slowly learn to incorporate that which allows them to handle the next steps they must make to attain the growth they need. But all in good time.
Therefore, parents must on the one hand shield and protect their children in the present but on the other prepare them for the future. There is a right and a wrong way to do this. Not enough shielding and protecting is not good. Too much is also not good. Some children are overprotected which essentially stunts their growth and disallows them from developing properly. Without a course correction this makes them incapable of being able to handle life and forces them to have virtually ongoing proactive assistance. It simply does not help their maturation to have a helicopter mom flying around them all the time, providing their every trifling need, and giving them ultra-shielding and protection by her constant presence. Yet many other children are subjected to far too much freedom and mature content at early ages at a time when they cannot properly deal with the subject matter. This inevitably gets them in trouble. Most would much prefer a loving parent close by.
OUR HEAVENLY FATHER
One would think the Lord does not engage in either of these extremes while raising His own children. Of course, He doesn’t. He will never spoil a child but He will also grant ultra-protection and shielding when required. Yet our Father obviously knows that children must grow to adulthood properly. The fact that there is a future adulthood which must inevitably be embraced is a simple hard fact of life and it does no good to shy away from it. Therefore, it is far better to prepare and be prepared rather than run from reality regardless of how cold and hard that reality may be.
For perspective, consider the Lord Jesus Himself. He was once a beautiful baby and a wonderful precious child. He truly was that perfect child we otherwise idealize. Yet He too had to grow out of childhood and begin the difficult trip to His destiny. I would say no one ever prepared as much as He did or was ever prepared to such a degree by His chosen parents. And then the day came when the former beautiful precious child filled with laughter and joy—God’s perfect spotless Lamb—had to endure the worst physical suffering any man ever endured and die an extremely difficult, painful, and traumatic death. When the time of His arrest arrived the onset evil to which He was suddenly subjected quickly advanced exponentially. His treatment grew worse by the minute and it appeared that His Father and all His friends and family had completely checked out on Him leaving Him vulnerable to a cast of the most wicked people who ever lived. This represented quite the contrast between the Lord’s former life as the holy Lamb of God and the Sacrifice Lamb who became sin on our behalf. It is also a genuine illustration of the fallen world in which we live.
We see then, that the existent hard world filled with potential sin and misery which every child must venture into must somehow be overcome. These are simply the cold hard facts of the matter. It is what it is. It is why good people who strive to be good parents of their precious children have great pause when considering the task before them. They want to shield and protect their children and they must, of course, but must also allow for the appropriate growth their children need to eventually become strong overcoming adults that can properly handle the world, stay on top of things, not be overcome by the sin and evil thereof, and also excel as subject-to-attack spiritual warriors.
THE SPIRITUAL SOLUTION
“Yet even now,” declares the Lord,
“Return to Me with all your heart,
And with fasting, weeping and mourning;
And rend your heart and not your garments.” [Joel 2:12-13]
Without the Lord’s presence in one’s life and His guidance people have a tendency to develop the very opposite of what the Lord prescribes such as a hard heart enveloped in a thick callus. This is due to the constant ongoing irritating friction and pressure one undergoes in attempting to make it in life and overpower the opposition one is subjected to. It is often the case that otherwise good-natured people become hardened due to what they must endure. This process also often causes people to have a “thin skin” in that one under the pressure of coping gives rise to raw emotion, is offended rather easily, becomes triggered at intervals, and on occasion even becomes ready for a fight. It is not because such intermittent displays are in their inherent nature but are due to the load of difficult things they have to bear at any given time. Again, it is an illustration of this fallen sinful world in which we live in that otherwise tender loving people become less so over time and are often hardened simply by the realities of persevering.
The Lord would rather things be the other way around. Rather than having thick hearts and tender skin, He would rather we have tender hearts and thick skin. Without a tender loving heart one is simply unable to communicate with God or understand Him. And without a thick skin which allows one to be protected and shielded from incessant offenses and ongoing pesky attacks, one cannot overcome such things and will succumb and be defeated. A tender heart also allows one to have close loving relationships with family and friends, of course.
We see then that it is an act of God that makes it possible for one to stay tender-hearted as a child but also develop great strength, a thick skin, a strong mind, a powerful attitude, and a spiritual backbone (like a saw log) toward defeating anything and everything that would hinder one’s vitally necessary ability, gifting, purpose, and destiny to overcome in life rather than be overcome by it. For this God has a plan in which He can maintain the pure and holy hearts of children within the mature spiritual warriors He must create both for His purposes and for our greater welfare and standing in Him.
VICTORY IN JESUS
He knows that His people must be victorious. We want to be victorious. This means gaining the victory, keeping the victory, and being the ongoing constant victor against all spiritual enemies demands tender hearts and thick skin yet there is only one way such can ever happen. It is never through our own efforts because such is effectively impossible. It can therefore only occur due to an act of God.
Trying to achieve this on our own develops the very opposite of what we want. It should be obvious that our own efforts only develop the hard heart-thin skin paradigm. Yet this world demands that we deal with very difficult issues and those who try to overcome and gain victory without the Lord, again, bring about the very reverse effect of that for which they are striving. It is a conundrum, no? An even bigger conundrum for those who otherwise rightly embrace taking responsible authority for their lives is the idea that one must surrender to God to gain the good life they seek. Many people recoil at such an idea because surrender is perceived as a bad word promoting weakness and irresponsibility that cannot possibly result in anything good.
So we come full circle. Though we may want to retain a childlike joyful heart and seek happiness in life we are instead conditioned and even coerced into rejecting such idealistic notions in order to grow up, develop a stiff upper lip, and achieve on our own doing whatever we must. Yet this results in an effective destruction of childhood innocence in which we end up far from God and really don’t appreciate what we become.
The Lord’s approach is just the opposite in that we must not only maintain the joyful attitude of a child but embrace it (which represents a tender heart) while also developing into full responsible adulthood (which represents a thick skin).
Such knowledge should clarify one’s perception of the Lord’s attitude toward His children. He is obviously Good. He is Love. No One has greater love. He gave His very life for His children. However, He also chastens those whom He loves. He subjects them to spiritual trials. He allows for tribulations and suffering. He demands a high level of obedient discipleship. All of these things are necessary for the removal of the old paradigm and application of the new one.
They are designed to tenderize our hearts and thicken our skin.
“I am the true vine, and My Father is the vinedresser. Every branch in Me that does not bear fruit, He takes away; and every branch that bears fruit, He prunes it so that it may bear more fruit.” [John 15:1-2]
“These things I have spoken to you so that My joy may be in you, and that your joy may be made full.” [John 15:11]
…We have not ceased to pray for you and to ask that you may be filled with the knowledge of His will in all spiritual wisdom and understanding, so that you will walk in a manner worthy of the Lord, to please Him in all respects, bearing fruit in every good work and increasing in the knowledge of God; strengthened with all power, according to His glorious might, for the attaining of all steadfastness and patience; joyously giving thanks to the Father, who has qualified us to share in the inheritance of the saints in Light.
For He rescued us from the domain of darkness, and transferred us to the kingdom of His beloved Son, in whom we have redemption, the forgiveness of sins. [Colossians 1:9b-14][1]
© 2025 by RJ Dawson. All Rights Reserved.
[1] Unless otherwise noted all Scriptures are taken from the New American Standard Bible, © 1960, 1963, 1968, 1971, 1972, 1973, 1975, 1977, 1995 by The Lockman Foundation. Used by permission.
Posted on March 27, 2025, in Teaching and tagged Blessed are the Pure in Heart, Discipleship, Heart Circumcision, Joy, Lamb of God, Lord Jesus, Paul, Real Christianity The Nature of the Church, Salvation in Jesus, Spiritual Warfare, The Everlasting Father, The Great Awakening, The Prophet Joel, The Sacrifice Lamb, The Way of Life, Trust Your Heart With God, Victory in Jesus, Wicked Heart of Unbelief. Bookmark the permalink. 5 Comments.



Great analogy, RJ. Thank you for writing and sharing.
LikeLike
Thanks Amber. I appreciate it. Blessings
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, RJ. This is a difficult topic and I may be missing the main thesis of the article.
From what I gather, each person is born with a hard heart by nature, and only the Lord Jesus can transform our hard hearts, but we must be born again. Two verses from the Old Testament come to mind:
1) Jeremiah 17:9 “the heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked; who can know it?”
2) Ezekiel 36:26 “I will give you a new heart and put a new spirit in you; I will remove from you your heart of stone and give you a heart of flesh.”
Blessings to you!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you Dee. For whatever reason, this was a difficult article to write. I started with a solid first draft but had to do a lot of editing. I finally got it into what I thought was the correct form but the subject matter was such that I could not arrive at the desired concise and precise level. I think it was meant to be parabolic in part. There was a lot more material I could have added, such as many Scripture verses which I gathered dealing with the need for a circumcised heart, like the one you mentioned from Ezekiel, but the volume would have been too great. The Lord in the OT mentioned this great need several times and I have written on the subject many times previously. The main point is as you said, that there must be a born again experience, an act of God, to change one’s hard heart to a tender heart.
I don’t think we are necessarily born with a hard heart but that we develop one over time to varying degrees as we get older. Little children are generally not bad nor do they have hard hearts though some pick up bad habits and bad information from sinful older kids and adults although they probably don’t really understand since such small children have yet to reach the age of accountability. The Lord spoke often of the good nature of children and even said we must become like children to enter His kingdom which means the heart of a child is something precious which He greatly appreciates:
At that time the disciples came to Jesus and said, “Who then is greatest in the kingdom of heaven?” And He called a child to Himself and set him before them, and said, “Truly I say to you, unless you are converted and become like children, you will not enter the kingdom of heaven. Whoever then humbles himself as this child, he is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven.” [Matthew 18:2-4]
Regarding Jeremiah 17:9, I remember reading a passage in one of John Eldredge’s books many years ago in which he revealed very strong opinions on why that verse is greatly taken out of context and misapplied. I had never thought about it too much before then but saw his point. I just read the entire chapter. It is not referring to humanity in general but is a part of Jeremiah’s rebuke of the tribe of Judah at that particular time 26 centuries ago. He certainly was not including his own heart due to what he says about himself in verse 18. He also could not have been including the faithful Remnant. Based on what the Lord Jesus said he also was likely not referring to children.
Regarding the concept of a wicked heart, I must also mention that if we graded people on the curve, it is highly likely that the majority portion of the nation of ancient Israel contained some of the very worst people on the planet. This should be obvious especially since the OT written record is their own history. The OT was not written by foreigners hostile to Israel but was written by their own writers as inspired and anointed by God. This helps us to know it is accurate. The OT was also confirmed by the Lord Jesus but some particulars thereof need a longer study to explain in full.
Again, thanks for writing and commenting. I hope the post was edifying. Blessings!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you, RJ for the further explanation. I am getting a clearer picture of your article. Yes, agree, it does not mean we are born with a hard heart to start with. Jesus stressed the importance of a pure heart – “out of the abundance of the heart, the mouth speaks.” Yes indeed your post is edifying as you have shed further light on it. Thank you, RJ.
LikeLiked by 1 person